On “Online Gaming and Virtual Worlds”

Published March 3, 2016 by sbuengwrt614

I have been never fond of playing any types of gaming, which literary includes any game that is associated with a screen and a controller. Watching parts of some particular gaming is a different story.

I contemplated why never any game attracted me….then suddenly it comes to my mind that it has a lot to do with the fact that I won’t get interested in things that are highly aesthetic. This realization comes from another but rather old self-realization of the fact that while I love to play sports for communal gratification, I have never enjoyed watching any kind of sports on television except for ice-skating. Ballet, dance, and ice-skating are the only sports my hearts strongly attracted to watch. Active participation in sports (games in the real world) have been entertaining for me, for the reason that allows me to exert my own physical ability, that is to say, there is an autonomy and the joy of doing some kind of experiments with my own brain and the body. That is why I enjoyed playing tennis, basket-ball…etc, and I never actually cared whether I would win or not. I realized that I cared about the art of sporting, and how would I improve or make the games more joyful for me, and pay no heed to what score I got; I vaguely imagine that probably no one can care less than I do in playing sports. “Competitions” is something taking place with myself, and not with others. I know that might sound strange to many of you, but it is who I am and I am merely giving a fact here. I don’t consciously compete with anything but my own expectations on myself and struggle to win the weakness over such self-competition. What does these personal disposition have to do with the reason why I never have fond of playing computer games, or other games such as X-box and Wii to name a few?

When I was a small kid, my brother got a Famicon (so called “family computer” ..gaming device), and invariably played Mario brothers like other kids. I watched him playing sometimes, frequently, but for a very short period of time. All I remember is the sound effects and the crude pixeled representations of characters on the screen, and the movements of Mario which I mimicked as a child, jumping up and down when we giggled and talked about the game with him. He offered me to try the game, and although I tried, nothing was particularly interesting for me. I would prefer sewing various things, doing embroideries, making collage, conduct various mediums of paintings (I still do love to do all these things…if I could manage to get some time) than clicking buttons and moving controllers in order to get intangible items and coins in the virtual world so that the gamer can “level-up.” I got no patience to play with the device until I “get it” as Stokel-Walker puts it in his “Second Life’s Strange Second Life”. And at the bottom of my heart, somehow I knew I would never “get them” because of my disposition and my preference centered on the reality and the real world activity. I vaguely remember he also played Street Fighters, but I am not too sure how much he had played that game because of my disinterest in games. Then years passed, and my brother got Play Stations. I remember he played Metal Gear Solid, series of Biohazard and Onimusha (I’m not talking about recent ones, though; I’m talking about Onimusha I and II, the ones that have produced long time ago. Besides, I assume that the last one might not be available outside Japan…officially; if the player is not familiar with the nature of oni (frequently translated as a devil, but this is misnomer considering the background and the wide variety of oni’s mentalities) and the Japanese History and Japanese historical novels (up until Edo period), then the game certainly won’t trigger the excitement and the appreciation that those who have knowledge could receive from the narrative). Metal Gear Solid impressed me a little bit because of the power of graphic design. I sometimes watch him playing, but that did not last long….maybe a few minutes, and that was enough for me. The latter two had quite different impacts on me….and I watched him playing quite a long time and ask him fervently about the story and begged me to call me whenever the point the game would reach the short movies that would appear when the gamer clears some stages. I watched for hours, although I never played them myself. Capcom’s capability in generating compelling narratives, aesthetically moving graphics that appeared quite realistic in strange but beautiful ways, and the perfectly suited musics (particularly the opening and ending sound tracks for Onimusha  were, to me at that time, indescribably great) that they asked the composers to create for their game, is astonishing. While Tom Bissell, in his essay, analyzes the driving force of games from the gamer’s point of view saying “the gamer’s curiosity: What happens next? What is over here? What if I do this?” I had a watcher’s curiosity: What happens next? What is over there? What if he does this? And precisely because I am not the one who was playing the game, I could enjoy the aesthetic quality of the virtual world and absorb myself to the narcotic beauty. The joy I received from watching the games he was playing, as if I were watching the movies, nourished my inspiration in writing. I felt I followed closely with the character that he was playing, and actively participated in the emotions (fear, tensions…etc) the proceedings of them gave me. Can I call this activity as a physically passive but mentally active involvement? Maybe.

The difference between Bissell who perceives that “Niko’s [the gamer’s character’s] real pathos derives not from the gimcrack story but how he looks and moves” in talking about Grand Theft Auto IV, the games that he loved the most, and me who perceived the pathos of the games in the story (they were by no means gimcrack, as far as I could recall for Onimusha and Biohazard series) more than how the gamer’s character looks and moves presumably derives from the fact that he is and was a gamer and I am a non-gamer. As once being an eager onlooker for these two games, I could easily imagine how addictive gaming could be (I saw my brother tended to stay up like Bissell (minus any sort of illegal chemicals nor drinks) when he was still in college, and I sometimes saw him playing free online games time to time after work even today) regardless of the modes of the games (single player or multiple players; my brother prefer the former the latter mode fell out from his taste quite quickly).

 

http://msp.c.yimg.jp/yjimage?q=MAACj_IXyLFjpnqMK5FHEE1ghiG0pYYCbqQM2ygeYYdHsucN4Cq3sWDtxMfxfFehhW4F8KEczOn5.3JmvQcSoQWzr1Ss8jB72TQh20hs9T9aMu4QF3sNnCQhkBEdhKlVOJ9VZF0JUphZYG2Wlg--&sig=1383kj2ij&x=208&y=242http://tn-skr2.smilevideo.jp/smile?i=20330893.L

Above and below: Ref. pics for Onimusha in this blog (right: http://msp.c.yimg.jp/yjimage?q=MAACj_IXyLFjpnqMK5FHEE1ghiG0pYYCbqQM2ygeYYdHsucN4Cq3sWDtxMfxfFehhW4F8KEczOn5.3JmvQcSoQWzr1Ss8jB72TQh20hs9T9aMu4QF3sNnCQhkBEdhKlVOJ9VZF0JUphZYG2Wlg–&sig=1383kj2ij&x=208&y=242, left: http://tn-skr2.smilevideo.jp/smile?i=20330893.L)

 

Above:  http://img0.ph.126.net/ffLpii9DSFtgjsrEXq2MyQ==/6597301763609471850.jpg

 

Rhetoric On Call: Rhetorical Problems with White Paper’s “Principles of Data Visualization”

Published February 25, 2016 by sbuengwrt614

First and for most— no offence.

I hope that the readers would realize my point being not about scientific accuracy of several important definitions that White Paper gives in “Principles of Data Visualization—What We See in a Visual,” but being on what it means to give no clear definition on some important concepts supporting their arguments potentially damages the ethos of their argument (although I would not discuss in this post, there are further problems in this article, such as improper word choice and bad choices for visual representations especially for the graphs).

Douglas Eyman devotes on the topic of “Data Visualization” in the third chapter of Digital Rhetoric: Theory, Method, Practice, in relation to Method, and I had no problem with his arguments: he is giving me the facts to make his point that matches the facts that I learned within these few years under the graduate courses I took (109-111). It is totally different story when it comes to the document of concern. “Principles of Data Visualization—What We See in a Visual,” produced by White Paper is available in PDF format, and it appears that the PDF was create with a purpose of spreading the effectiveness of data visualization and convince the readers to ultimately become one of the clients that they are boasting as “22,000 customers and 500,000 developers in 120 countries including organizations like NASA, Microsoft, Cisco, GE, AT&T and World Bank use FusionCharts Suite XT to go from data to delight in minutes” (15). Ouch. If the writer dares to (of course they do…its’ marketing) list mega company and even a government institute as their clients, they should have been better off to give readers the definitions on too famous concepts such as Long-Term Memory, Working Memory, and Gestalt principles, as well as to pay attention to avoid using improper (actually offensive) words: “normal, abnormal” (7-13).

In this article, White Paper defines Long-Term memory as “[t]his type of memory is what makes us always expect the units to be marked off on the X and Y axes of a chart, or the date range selector at the top of a dashboard. This type of memory is formed by past interactions and experiences”….what!? What are you talking about? Where is the definition? No, by all means, that is not even a definition. Such an example (instead of giving solid definition of what the term means) might have been chosen because they had only their designed readers in their mind then the example might work out as they hoped for. But one thing they are missing here is that they lose the potential for wider clients by cutting short of so-called “regular audience” including college and graduate students. Well, for those who have utilized Excel or familiar with the methods in Digital Humanity, it makes sense—but not strikingly apparent—because the definition is missing. It is out of scope for them to talk about the controversy over current scientific understanding of the Long-term memory, but still, it would make much more sense if they have defined the term as “Long-term memory is often referred as ‘memory’ in people’s daily conversation, and this is a type of memory that is considered as relatively permanent,” and add much easier example that would be instinctively comprehended such as “it is like the storage of information on a hard drive in the PC with an exception that it is almost limitless in its capacity,” before moving on to give more specific analogy as they did in their article.

Then comes the problem with subsequent description of  Working memory. For my argumentative purpose, I won’t go in depth about the lack of the terms’ definition, but I need to tell you that what they are stating here is not even facts….if they are, I wonder where they drew the information from: “our working memory can hold only about 3 chunks of information at any given time” (7). On average, it has been known that our working memory appears to exert its maximum effect when it is “3 chunks of information” at a time. But it is not “at any given time” and also known to vary among individuals. “Chunking” is, by definition (in Neuroscientific and Psychological term), the process of breaking down perceived information into meaningful units. As far as I remember, one of the English Journal article written by a literary scholar and teacher, which was especially issued toward audience in teacher’s education program, gives the definition precisely like this. What is known by now scientifically is that working memory is limited, and the memory span is limited to SEVEN items or fewer at a time. Now, you realize the difference. White paper appears to have not paying attention to the rhetorical consequence of making such a misleading argument in a definite way. “At any given time” is pretty determinative expression, and “can hole about 3 chunks of information” does not apply to all of us because some people chunks more at a time, and the upper maximum is 7, not 3.

The same issues arise in their definition of Gestalt’s Principles. To be brief, Gestalt’s Principle captures the function of our brain to compensate the space that appears “missing” from our past visual experiences. In other words, our sights will automatically “fill-in” the blanks that appears to be missing from what we see. Let’s compare this basic concept with what they say: “Gestalt principles describe how our mind organizes individual elements into groups” (11). I don’t know how majority of you would feel, but I felt their statement is too vague and open ended.

Digital Rhetoric is, as Eyman states clearly in his book, in the realm of Rhetoric. It goes against the purpose if the Method description violates the efficacy of Rhetoric. Companies selling their product by fully utilizing rhetorics, especially the product has to do with enhancing Digital Rhetoric, they need to pay attention to not to lose their ethos like White Paper does.

Online Identities, Digital Bodies, Race/Gender

Published February 18, 2016 by sbuengwrt614

I have never been a gamer, far from been interested in almost any science fictions, nor been a fan virtual reality (VR) no matter how painful my “real life” (RL) have been, yet I am able to empathize the “real” (including genuine feelings of users behind the screen) felt through Julian Dibbell’s “A Rape in Cyberspace.”  Some people with similar taste like me, who uses the internet only as a tool in enhancing the RL by obtaining information and articles that would be applicable to RL, might go so far to say that living in the world of VR is a mere escapism from RL, but I have quite different opinion: it is a matter of personal tastes and choices. On that note, which I hope I have make it very clear that I am not prejudiced against the world of VR or the users who are fascinated with living in the community of VR, I argue that Dibbell’s idea that “recognizing in a full-dodied way that what happens inside a MUD-made world is neither exactly real nor exactly make-believe, but nonetheless profoundly, compellingly, and emotionally true” (n.p.) is quite to the point. Take fanatic fans of a baseball team or a novel, say, Harry Potter (again, it’s a little shame to confess that I am not a fan of neither, but I’d like to be honest), and think about how they would react toward the team they cherishes very much or the characters the fans adore so much. These fans’ emotional attachment to their target of interest is so strong and powerful that they would quarrel and even fight (verbally and physically) when they feel that their target of adoration got insulted or tainted by negative comments. Enthusiastic fans’ mentality in the real world could be almost analogous to the mentality of the users who are totally into their VR. No matter how remote the community of VR appears for those who do not live in any types of VR, emotional values that heavy users would have on the incidents of VR can be as real and as valuable as we feel in RL. Violation and abuse through words and other means on the cyberspace should not be neglected, as much as no crime should be overlooked in the real world.  As Dibbell points out, in VR, it is a tricky and difficult task to create so called “lawful” environment that is applicable just inside of the VR community like LamdaMOO because it is tied to the problem of the freedom of speech. Nonetheless, VR violence against individual users should be deal seriously for the reason that I have mentioned earlier.

One of the things that caught my eye in Dibbell’s article “A Rape in Cyberspace,” which I feel I am compelled to discuss about is on her statement,

Sometimes… it grew difficult for me to understand why RL society classifies RL rape alongside crimes against person or property. Since rape can occur without any physical pain or damage… then it must be classed as a crime against the mind — more intimately and deeply hurtful, to be sure, than cross burnings, wolf whistles, and virtual rape, but undeniably located on the same conceptual continuum. (n.p.)

The reason “why RL society classifies RL rape alongside crimes against person or property” (n.p, italics with emphasis), I argue, is that the mind—intellectual property and emotional property—are included in the property and it is tied to a person, thus they phrase it person or property in the First Amendment. It is inclusive.

Reference: A Rape in Cyberspace

Eyman’s Digital Rhetoric: Theory

Published February 11, 2016 by sbuengwrt614

With an effort to build comprehensive and coherent theory of “digital rhetoric,”  Eyman argues in the chapter 2 of his Digital Rhetoric that we should consider digital rhetoric as a field of rhetoric comprised of “multiple theories and methods  rather than as a single theory framework” (61). In this chapter, Eyman conducts extensive review of contemporary digital rhetoric theory focusing on the development of the theory and the extensive application of it. As Eyman clarified in the previous chapter, digital rhetoric grounds its nature in rhetoric. When it comes to try to theorize a concept or a field of study, it is essential to go back to the basics. Back to the basics—this attitude is literary rhetorically essential for Eyman to convince readers, especially because he is aware of the fact that “[i]n terms of “applying and revising traditional rhetorical theory, there is a distinct division between scholars who focus on classical rhetoric and those who prefer to engage in contemporary theory” (61). Therefore, he starts from reviewing the classical five canons of rhetoric; invention, arrangement, style, memory, and delivery, before discussing further about contemporary rhetorical theories. Although some of the latter theories have a problem of inconsistency in their arguments but worth considering for their ingenious analogical applications of ecosystem, ecology, economics to the theories of digital rhetorics.

۩ 5 Canons of Classical Rhetoric

  Invention

             Arrangement

             Style

             Memory

             Delivery

When we think of Classic Rhetoric in general, the figures come into our mind are presumably first Aristotle, then Cicero (I am talking about a non-expert like me). However, in terms of the usefulness for applying the concepts into digital texts and digital world, what fits the most is neither of them: Sophistic rhetoric. Eyman explains the rational as follows:

Sophistic rhetoric, with its focus on both literacy and orality and a clear sense of situated activity and sociocultural relativism, certainly is well suited for addressing issues of multimedia presentation and the function of digital text circulation within particular social and electronic networks. (63)

Drawing on Jarret’s idea, Eyman points out that sophistic rhetoric is particularly useful because of “its focus on probability (and denial of absolute truth): ‘Acknowledging an epistemological status for probability demands in discourse a flexible process of ordering or arranging, a feature of both nomos (a social construct involving ordering) and narrative’(Jarratt, 1991, 47)” (63). Flexibility and fluidity is essential entities in formulating the theory of digital rhetoric, considering the digital environment where many materials posted online has been unstable for the most part. Any webpages might be added at this moment, as well as any of them could be deleted at the same moment.

Eyman summarizes the five canons of classical rhetoric, their use, and their application to digital practice in a table (Table 2.1) on page 65 in Digital Rhetoric (2015).

Table 2.1

Canon Classical Definition/Use Digital Practice
Invention finding available means of persuasion searching and negotiating networks of information; using multimodal and multimedia tools
Arrangement formalized organization manipulating digital media as well as selecting ready-made works and reconstituting them into new works; remixing
Style ornamentation/appropriate form understanding elements of design (color, motion, interactivity, font choice, appropriate use of multimedia, etc.)
Delivery oral presentation understanding and using systems of distribution (including the technical frameworks that support varying protocols and networks)
Memory memorization of speech information literacy—knowing how to store, retrieve, and manipulate information (personal or project-based; blogs or databases)

 

Further discussions Eyman makes on contemporary theories center on the issue of Network, Digital Ecologies, Economies of circulation with the emphasis on how these concepts can be useful exploring or extrapolating the theory of digital rhetoric. The most striking yet interesting analogy to me is the application of the partial concept of biological ecosystem to digital environment. At first, I was puzzled by wondering how come such an application be possible, but as I read on, it made sense to me. Eyman’s following explanation clarifies the legitimacy of the metaphorical application of the ideas from the study of ecology on digital environment:

A scientific term originally applied to research on interactions in specific natural environments, “ecology” as a metaphor for complex, interconnected relationships has a rich history of use in writing studies (Cooper, 1986; Syverson, 1999; Nardi & O’Day, 1999; Spinuzzi & Zachry, 2000; Spinuzzi, 2003; Blythe, 2007).The basic scientific definition of ecology is “the study of the relationships of organisms to their environment and to one another. The key word is ‘relationships.’ Ecology is a study of interactions” (Brewer, 1988, 1); another key aspect of the science of ecology is the study of the ecosystem: ecology can be applied as the “ecology of the individual organism [or] the ecology of groups of individuals or populations,” when taking the latter approach, it is important to acknowledge that “populations live together in communities—the community along with its physical setting or habitat is a single, interacting unit, the ecosystem” (11). Thus, the key elements of ecological study—relationships, interaction, complexity, and community—easily map onto qualitative studies of writing and rhetoric in both epistemological and ontological terms.

By clarifying how they are conceptually not only valid but also valuable when they are applied to the study of digital rhetoric, Eyman borrows Bunge’s argument and points out that:

Ecology is also a useful framework for a theory of rhetorical circulation because it provides a systems-based view of both the environments and relationships that take place through digital circulation mechanisms. Systems are characterized by their compositions, environments, and structures (Bunge, 1979). (85)

 

My questions for our class discussion are as follows:

  1. Can anyone explain for me in layman’s terms what “descriptive tags” mean on page 69?
  2. Eyman says “it may also be left up to the user, as in the case of hypertext, where the reader creates a new arrangement with each reading,” (68) when he is discussing on the subject of Arrangement. Unless the interface providers or organizers allow their users to modify or write into a webpage, how does what Eyman claim above could be possible? What Eyman is referring to then?
  3. How do you define digital identity? Is it fictional or realistic, or mixture of both to you? Do you agree with Eyman’s support on Bay’s argument “’what we do online now requires there to be more continuity—or at least fluidity—between our online and off-line selves’ (155)” (79)?
  1. What exactly is “non-human actors” after all? (“materials” (82) mean nothing as an answer to me. Technically speaking, there is no such thing as cyborg (well, not in SF sense)…so how do you define it? I have no idea, so can anyone help me with your idea?)

“Definingand Locating Digital Rhetoric” in Eyman, Digital Rhetoric Ch.1

Published February 4, 2016 by sbuengwrt614

 

In the first chapter of Digital Rhetoric, Douglas Eyman meticulously examines contemporary definitions of “digital rhetoric” given by quite a large number of scholars and their works, and explains nit-picking details of how unsatisfactory, misleading, or being out of scope they have been, while some points these scholars make have potentially useful application in establishing a firm sense of what “digital rhetoric” means. For Eyman, the definition of “digital rhetoric” should include the essence of production, cultural and social context and the consideration for social action that digital rhetoric might evoke. Eyman agrees that the field of digital rhetoric has just opened, and there are strong potential for the field to grow with much more solid understanding about it. In defining “digital rhetoric,” Eyman follows Zappen’s idea from “Digital Rhetoric: Toward an Integrated Theory” (29):

the use of rhetorical strategies in production and analysis of digital text

identifying characteristics, affordances, and constrains of new media

formation of digital identities

potential for building social communities ( Zappen 319)

and defines these items as “the primary activities within the field of digital rhetoric” (44), and continues on to add more items to the list in order to make the definition more inclusive and comprehensive:

inquiry and development of rhetorics of technology

the use of rhetorical methods for uncovering and interrogating ideologies and  cultural formation in digital work

an examination of the rhetorical function of networks

theorization of agency when interlocutors are as likely to be software agents (or “spimes”) as they are human actors (44)

Among all the items in Eyman’s list, I found the last one “theorization of agency when interlocutors are as likely to be software agents (or “spimes”) as they are human actors” quite problematic for the same reason that I concerned about Eyman’s suggestion that “some of the issues that arise within computational rhetoric, such as consideration of whether nonhuman agents can engage in rhetorical communication is an important question for digital rhetoric as well” (43). Suppose it is possible, does it mean we should attempt to achieve such artificial intelligence just because it would be useful? What would be the severe downside of achieving such a high artificial intelligence? Considering the extremely complicated networks and webs that are created by thousands of millions of neurons and synapsis in our brains, and the way the ideas in our mind have find its way to exit the high-speed circuit into mouth or hands to create either oral, visual, or textual representation (or combinations of them), it seems almost impossible to achieve to create an AI with the same intellectual complexity that human beings have. Moreover, suppose if any scholars and/or scientists found a way to create such almost-human AI, I hope they are sensible enough to put the knowledge into practice without considering the inherent danger behind achieving such highly intellectual AI, in order not to repeat the similar mistake Einstein made for the creation of atomic bomb.

 

Create your own website, free on WordPress.com.Create your own website.
Start free